Black actors in Canada must work significantly harder just to receive the same level of recognition as their peers writes Nyla McEwan.
“The goal isn’t just one award. The goal is an industry where Black actors don’t have to work ten times as hard just to be seen.” -Jennie Esnard
Michael B. Jordan took home his first Oscar for Best Actor on March 15, 2026, at the 98th Academy Awards for his performance in Sinners. Audiences describe this as one of his best films yet. Unfortunately, throughout award season, leading up to the Oscars, there was an outcry online about him not winning another award as he went home emptyhanded. Fans and critics questioned how one of the year’s most talked about performances could go unrecognized. This reviving a long-running debate in the film industry: why Black actors often appear to have to work harder and achieve more to receive the same level of recognition as their white peers.
During 2026 Critics Choice Awards, the award for Best Actor instead went to Timothée Chalamet for his role in Marty Supreme; a decision that quickly sparked debate about recognition, fairness and a familiar frustration in the film industry. For many viewers, the moment felt like something they had seen before. Another acclaimed performance by a Black actor. Another award that went elsewhere.
And another reminder, some say, that Black performers often must work significantly harder just to receive the same level of recognition as their peers.
A Canadian lens
While the debate unfolded largely in Hollywood, the conversation resonates across the film industry, including in Canada. For actors and instructors working within Canada’s growing television and film sector, the question of recognition is tied to a deeper issue: access to opportunity.
“I knocked on many doors, and I was told, ‘we have one Black person, we don’t need anymore.” – Jennie Esnard
Jennie Esnard, an acting instructor at Screen Acting Academy Ottawa and an Alliance of Canadian Cinema, Television and Radio Artists (ACTRA) union activist, says the challenges for Black performers often start long before awards season.
“There are a lot of things that should have been red flags back then,” Esnard said.
Esnard has spent years working in the acting industry and mentoring students who hope to break into it. Through that work, she says she has seen how difficult the path can be for Black performers trying to establish themselves.
The obstacles often begin with auditions and casting calls. “I knocked on many doors, and I was told, ‘we have one Black person, we don’t need anymore,” she said.
For aspiring actors, hearing those words can make it clear how limited opportunities can be. While performers of all backgrounds face competition, she says Black actors frequently encounter an additional layer of barriers; fewer roles written for them and fewer chances to prove themselves. That reality can create constant pressure to stand out.
That pressure is echoed by others working in and around the industry.
Jay Willy, an emerging Black singer, rapper and songwriter, says the issue is not always direct, but still deeply felt.
“There’s less room for mistakes and fewer opportunities overall,” he said. “So, when chances come, you have to be sharper, more consistent, and stand out more to get noticed.”
He adds that representation growing up was also limited.
“You’d see Black characters, but they weren’t always the main focus or fully developed.” He says that lack of depth still affects how audiences connect with characters today.
“A lot of times they were side characters or fit into certain stereotypes, so it didn’t always feel relatable.”
In practical terms, that pressure can mean putting in more time preparing auditions, building networks, and refining skills. For some performers, it also means constantly worrying about mistakes that others might easily recover from. When opportunities are scarce, a single missed chance can feel like a major setback.
The idea that Black performers must exceed expectations to succeed has long been discussed in film and television. Throughout movie history, many actors of colour like Denzel Washington, Viola Davis, and John Boyega have spoken about needing exceptional performances to break through industry barriers.
Even then, recognition has not always followed.
“Black actors often appear to have to work harder and achieve more to receive the same level of recognition as their white peers.” -Nyla McEwan
The award show problem
Awards shows have an enormous influence in the entertainment industry. Winning a major award can reshape an actor’s career, opening doors to larger roles, higher pay, better contracts, and greater visibility. Because of that influence, decisions about those who receive recognition often carry broader meaning.
Despite Michael B. Jordan eventually winning an Oscar, the broader history of the Academy Awards still reflects long-standing gaps in recognition for Black performers and filmmakers. Jordan became only the sixth Black actor to win Best Actor in Oscars history. In the Best Director category, no Black filmmaker has ever won. The pattern extends into supporting categories as well, with only six Black male actors winning Best Supporting Actor and nine Black actresses winning Best Supporting Actress. For critics and audiences, those numbers reinforce the argument that Black artists often face greater barriers to industry recognition, even at the highest levels.
And to raise bigger concerns, many in the Black community believe that the Black performances that do get recognized tend to play into Black stereotypes, especially for Black actresses.
Some examples: Teyana Taylor in One Battle After Another, Halle Berry in Monster’s Ball, Mo’Nique in Precious, based on the Novel ‘Push’ by Sapphire, and Luptia Nyong’o in 12 Years a Slave. All of these are considered award-worthy performances, worthy to be recognized, but still rely on stereotypes that portray Black woman as overly sexualized or limited to a servant-style roles. At the same time, highly praised films such as The Woman King were largely shut out of major award categories. The criticism grew even stringer after an anonymous Oscar voter admitted they had not watched the film before voting, raising further questions about fairness and whose stories are truly valued within the industry.
When audiences saw Jordan lose the award for Sinners, many interpreted the moment as part of a larger pattern. The debate echoes discussions that have surrounded awards ceremonies for years. In the mid-2010s, the social media movement #OscarsSoWhite drew global attention to the lack of diversity among nominees at major award shows.
The ongoing representation problem
“There’s this unspoken expectation to be exceptional, not just good, to really break through. It’s not just about being seen, it’s about how we’re seen.” -Mikayla Nembhard
Over the past decade, conversations about representation in film and television have become louder. Actors, filmmakers, and audiences increasingly use social media and public platforms to call attention to gaps in recognition and opportunity.
Mikayla Nembhard, a Canadian television producer and host of the On The Path Show on YES TV, says the expectation to excel is often unspoken but widely understood.
“There’s this unspoken expectation to be exceptional, not just good, to really break through,” she said. She adds that representation is not just about visibility, but depth. “It’s not just about being seen, it’s about how we’re seen.”
She also mentions that authenticity is what separates meaningful representation from stereotypes.
“When a character feels like a full human being with complexity and individuality, that’s when it feels real.”
The criticism prompted organizations across the film industry to review their nomination processes and voting bodies. Some changes followed, including new diversity initiatives and expanded membership among award voters.
Still, actors and advocates say progress has been uneven. Many of those challenges appear during the day-to-day work of acting.
Early in her career, Esnard remembers noticing details on set that revealed how unprepared some productions were to work with diverse casts.
“One thing that stood out was having to bring my own makeup bag,” she said.
For actors, that kind of experience may seem like a small detail. But for many performers, it reflects deeper structural gaps within the industry. A production environment designed primarily for white performers can send subtle signals about who the industry expects to see on screen.
Over time, those signals can shape how actors view their place within the profession.
“A lot of Black people in theatre and film are making opportunities for ourselves…People get very tired of showing up for auditions that fit the same stereotypes over and over.” – Cheryl Foggo
In Canada, the film and television sector has grown rapidly in recent decades. Cities such as Toronto and Vancouver have become major production hubs, attracting international studios and streaming platforms. The country’s film industry benefits government incentives, experienced crews, and diverse filming locations.
As a result, Canada has become one of the busiest production environments in the world. But as the industry expands, questions about representation remain.
Cheryl Foggo, a Canadian filmmaker, playwright and historian, says the need to create opportunities reflects deeper systemic gaps.
“A lot of Black people in theatre and film are making opportunities for ourselves,” she said.
She adds that storytelling and access are closely connected. “If the infrastructure is excluding Black voices, then the opportunities are negatively impacted.”
She also says that limited roles can shape how actors are seen and cast.
“People get very tired of showing up for auditions that fit the same stereotypes over and over.”
Many performers say diversity is discussed more openly today than it was in the past. However, turning those conversations into meaningful change can be slow.
Part of the challenge lies in the number of roles available to Black actors. When those roles exist, they may be limited or tied to stereotypes, leaving performers competing for a narrow range of characters. Actors hoping to build long careers often find themselves searching for roles that allow them to fully demonstrate their abilities.
For many performers, persistence becomes the defining feature of their career. Actors spend years building portfolios, attending auditions and forming connections within the industry. But when opportunities remain limited, that journey can feel longer and more uncertain.
Recognition can help change that trajectory.
“People are paying attention more now.” – Jennie Esnard
Gregory Ellison III, a film viewer and pop culture enthusiast, says the issue is visible even from an audience perspective.
“A lot of the time, Black actors give amazing performances and still get overlooked,” he said. He also points out the lack of variety in roles. “I want to see Black actors in everything, not just the same stories over and over.”
He says meaningful representation requires intention, not just visibility.
“It feels like sometimes they just add a Black character without really thinking about the impact.”
Awards and nominations often influence which actors are considered for future roles. They also help shape public perceptions of which performances deserve attention. When Black actors receive major recognition, it can challenge long-standing assumptions about who belongs at the centre of major productions.
That is why moments like Jordan’s awards-season loss can resonate so strongly with audiences. To some viewers, the outcome of an awards show reflects subjective preferences among voters. To others, it highlights patterns that have shaped careers for decades.
The debate surrounding Jordan’s performance in Sinners spread quickly online, with fans sharing scenes from the film and praising the emotional intensity of his performance. Many argued the role required a level of commitment and range that should have been rewarded. For Esnard, the public reaction reflects a growing awareness about inequality within the industry.
“People are paying attention more now.”
Those conversations have encouraged some studios and organizations to introduce programs supporting underrepresented voices.
In Canada, industry groups have created initiatives like Reelworld Screen Institute and Black Screen Office aimed at improving diversity both in front of and behind the camera. Advocates say that change is important because representation behind the scenes can shape the types of stories that appear on screen.
When writers, directors, and producers come from diverse backgrounds, they may be more likely to support narratives that reflect a wider range of experiences. Still, the pace of progress can feel slow for performers currently navigating the industry. Some actors say they continue to encounter the same challenges that existed years ago, limited roles, fewer auditions, and the constant need to prove their worth.
“When people see themselves represented and celebrated, it shows them it’s possible.” -Jennie Esnard
But representation works both ways. When actors, like Jordan, are snubbed, many audience members feel overlooked and discarded. But when they see a Black actor win or watch a film that authentically portrays the Black experience, they feel empowered.
It can also inspire younger performers who hope to pursue careers in film and television. Visibility, Esnard says, can make a real difference.
“When people see themselves represented and celebrated, it shows them it’s possible,” she said.
The debate surrounding Jordan’s awards-season loss illustrates how quickly a single moment can spark larger conversations. What began as disappointment over one award quickly grew into a broader discussion about fairness, opportunity and recognition.
For many observers, the frustration was not only about Jordan but about a long history of similar moments across the entertainment industry.
For Esnard, however, the larger goal goes beyond individual wins.
“The goal isn’t just one award,” she says. “The goal is an industry where Black actors don’t have to work ten times as hard just to be seen.”
Related content:
